Donna – I HATE YOU

Don’t tell mom, okay?” Donna whispered as she led me through the bedroom window onto the rooftop.

We sat down on the shingled surface, facing the small forest of pine trees that marked the end of our property line below us.

She was beautiful, with long, straight light brown hair, brown eyes, freckles.  She wore plain clothes, hiking boots most of the time.

Donna was a nature girl, always in the woods.  She did her own thing most of the time.

I was ten, almost eleven. She was five years older, and my idol.

She pulled out the pack and shook two ciggarettes out.  They were Twist lemon-flavored ciggarettes in an inviting, bright yellow pack.

She handed me one and lit a match.  Donna carefully taught me how to smoke, to first pull in air to get the end lit, then to blow out.  She said it was too soon for me to learn how to inhale.  There was plenty of time for that later.

I had never known her to be so attentive.

There was no coughing, just a sharp feeling on the back of my throat when I drew in the first puff. The second toke was smoother, more natural.  I took to smoking easily, as if it was meant to be.

We sat, puffing and staring at the night sky.  Hiding from the rest of the world, we had a secret from mom and everyone else.  Christine was too young to join us – she was only 9 for heaven’s sake!

Just me and Donna, and our own little secret.

I was high on life; the mysterious, cool girl who always found me completely disinteresting was suddenly paying me attention.

That was one of the few private, close moments we shared before her death.  One I’ll never forget.

Donna died at age 16 in 1976.  There’s a huge collection of poetry she wrote before she died.  This is one:


I hate you.

You wouldn’t

(and couldn’t)


how much.

I hate you!

I detest you!

I hate you –

you, you, you!


does it



D. Lehr 10/8/75


Donna – The 7 Memories of Seeing him on Sundays

Just about a week before we never saw her again, Donna did two very strange things.

First, she died her long, brown hair blonde.  It didn’t match with her freckles or flannel shirts, but she followed an urge to do something dramatic.

Then, she decided to paint the walls in her bedroom black.  In our hectic household, doing such things were allowed, because the “old man” hadn’t entered our bedrooms in over a decade, and mom believed in creative expression.

The room was walk-in-closet small, with one little window overlooking a large oak tree and the driveway.  The oak tree had a strong, fat branch which had served as a bridge for many a boyfriend, jumping from the adjoining rooftop into her window late at night.

Her bedroom door was ill-fitting, like a lid that doesn’t close tight.  There was just an open doorway when mom and dad bought the house.  Craving privacy, Donna enlisted a couple neighborhood guys to help her lift a door from an old abandoned house in the Rochelle Meadows woods.  They hung it in her doorway, slightly cock-eyed from the hinges, but it did the trick.  She had her sanctuary from little sisters and the enemy, which was anyone over 18.

Her single bed mattress was on the floor.  She never liked the idea of being like anyone else.  And if mom did even one thing right, it was that she let us be different.

Donna stole a can of glossy black from the back of the old man’s VW van, along with a paint roller and brushes.

She swept her new bleach-blonde hair up into a pony tail and started painting.  All four walls, from ceiling to floor, transformed black.  The only part left white was her ceiling, which had become a place for local graffiti, with sayings scrawled across it, such as:

We are the people our parents warned us about” and “Love is the answer, what was the question” and “Lonnie was here.”

One of the last things I remember seeing of Donna was a black streak of paint in her ponytail.  Her head swirling quickly, a glimpse of her nose.  After she died, it was hard for me to picture her face.

I still don’t think of her as a blonde, though she has appeared in many of my dreams that way.

Donna died at age 16 in 1976.  There’s a huge collection of poetry she wrote before she died.  This is one.


1 – Driving down the highway –

going to see you.

The wind blows on me –

it feels good.

Nothing feels better

than being lazy

in a  warm car –

with the window

a fraction of an inch open;

the wind blowing on


Feeling good.

Feeling happy.


Not free like a bird;

cause I’m not flying –


Not right now;


2 – Red, green, gold, and brown

colors pass through my eyes.

Clumps of bright red –

are the prettiest;

to me.

It’s the trees.

They’re turning;


Changing from their green summer clothes,

to fabulous different

color arrangements.

Keep on changing –

I love it.

I love you.

3 – Just woke up.

Feel good;

After an early morning nap.

My muscles feel dead,

like they’ve been electrocuted


My toes feel slightly cold;

but I like it.

I like it.

Yea –

I like it.

Don’t even mind

my ears popping

going through the mountains,

cause I’m getting there.

Closer and closer –

I’m getting there.



4 – The mist

hangs low over the valley –

causing your senses

to be out

of order;

for it looks like a sea –

with uprising waves of

cotton candy.

Looks so yummy –

think I’ll eat it.

But I couldn’t.

Just couldn’t.

No –


5 – Holding you close to me,

me loving you,

you loving me –

it –

it’s just so…


You’re beautiful,

I’m beautiful,

we’re beautiful,

everyone’s beautiful.

But most of all –

You’re beautiful.



6 – On the road again,

only minutes after

getting a good-bye kiss

from you,

the last one –


I come see you again;

next Sunday.

I thought that

if I held you

long enough

and tight enough,

we wouldn’t have to


It didn’t work.

It didn’t,


You’re gone,


7 – As the days go by

I’ll think of you;

remember you,

and love you.

Love you.

Love you.

I love you.

I love you.

Love –


Only you,


D. Lehr 10/5/75

Donna – You Know I Don’t Know

Donna stole our father’s button-down flannel shirts, wore them often, even though she weighed all but 95 pounds and was tiny, tiny, tiny.

My mother would say later that she did that because it was her way of being close to him.  He ignored her terribly.

I often wonder if he even cared that she died.

I don’t think so – how can you miss someone that you never got to know?

Donna died at age 16 in 1976.  There’s a huge collection of poetry she wrote before she died.  This is one.


You know –

me talking to you

lately has been

bringing me down.

Because I know

that what I’ve been doing,

isn’t right.

It’s the same stuff

that I say and pray

to you every night.

And lately it’s getting

so that

I don’t do anything new;

at all.

I feel bad;


And I want you to help me.

But you knew that.

You knew that.

You know –

me talking to you

lately has been

bringing me down –


You know?


I don’t Know…

I love you.

But then why

am I doing this?

I don’t know,

I don’t understand.

I can’t seem to.

Help me –

Dear God –

If you can hear me;

Help me!!

I know I’ve done wrong –

but I’m enjoying it.

Is this

some sort

of a


I don’t know.

If so –

Is it good –

or bad?

Help me.

Help me,


I just…

I don’t know…

D. Lehr 10/4-5/1975